- 1Main Title (The Second Star to the Right) / All This Has Happened Before2:18
- 2The Last Night in the Nursery3:00
- 3On the Rooftop / What’s a Kiss? / Perturbed Pixie4:05
- 4You Can Fly! You Can Fly! You Can Fly!4:24
- 5A Pirate’s Life0:29
- 6Blast That Peter Pan / A Pirate’s Life (reprise)1:04
- 7The Legend of the Croc / Double the Powder and Shorten the Fuse / Follow Tinker Bell4:40
- 8Just When I Brought You a Mother / Banished0:52
- 9Following the Leader1:42
- 10Hide and Sneak / No Let ’em Go1:15
- 11Mermaid Lagoon / Bad Day at Skull Rock4:30
- 12Plotting a Pixie’s Plight0:54
- 13What Made the Red Man Red? / Tinknapped2:44
- 14Rumor Has It / Hangman’s Tree2:37
- 15Big Chief Flying Eagle / I Had a Mother Once1:27
- 16Your Mother and Mine1:58
- 17Good‐Bye Peter / Shanghaied0:55
- 18Captain Hook Never Breaks a Promise / The Elegant Captain Hook / A Little Surprise / Oh Tink / The Pen or the Plank3:19
- 19No Splash / Take That / I’m a Codfish! / Crocbait / The Hero of Neverland4:09
- 20Home Again / Mermaids, Pirates and Indians / Finale (You Can Fly! You Can Fly! You Can Fly!)2:10
- 21Never Smile at a Crocodile1:44
- 22The Boatswain’s Song (demo)3:06
